Crash-test ratings are among the most important safety data you can find, but the different systems and labels can be hard to compare. A little context makes them far more useful.
The two main systems
- NHTSA – a familiar five-star overall rating from the federal government
- IIHS – ratings from Poor to Good, plus Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+ awards
- Both test different crash scenarios, so they complement rather than duplicate each other
What strong results look like
A genuinely safe car tends to earn five NHTSA stars and IIHS Good ratings across the board, ideally with a Top Safety Pick award. Models like the Subaru Outback, Mazda CX-5, and Honda Accord have frequently hit those marks on recent model years. Look for consistency across both systems rather than fixating on a single number.
A VIP Score folds these ratings into the bigger picture so you do not have to interpret them in isolation.
Vehicles named here are well-known examples cited for illustration and reflect these models’ general reputations across sources like EPA fuel-economy data and NHTSA and IIHS safety testing. Ratings vary by model year, trim, and engine, so always run the exact vehicle through the VIP Score before you buy.